Fallacies Bingo! About Contact

Your cycling fallacy is…

People break the rules when cycling

“People frequently break the rules of the road when cycling (ignoring red lights, etc.)”

The response

Much attention is paid to the issue of people cycling through stop signals, whereas the truth is that, regardless of the mode of travel used, some people will break traffic rules. People are no more likely to break traffic laws when they are cycling than when they are driving or walking.

There is some evidence to suggest that where the road design is poor (usually because the environment has been designed only with motor vehicles in mind), intentionally cycling through a red stop light can be safer. Thus the most visible form of “red light jumping” by people cycling is when someone sets off before the traffic signals turn green, in order to safely pass through the junction before motor traffic begins moving. Therefore some rule-breaking behaviour could be a reaction to a dangerously-designed environment – although that doesn't absolve someone who cycles in a manner hazardous to others, however.

Good public infrastructure, designed with cycling in mind as a valid mode of transport, makes rule-breaking less attractive and/or necessary. The bad behaviour of some should not be used as an argument against improving conditions for all (a point that doesn't even need making for other modes of transport).